thoughts on communism and capitalist?
I personally believe that communism is the best government. Many communism countries failed during the cold war because of the idiotic leaders at that time. During stalin's rule, he adopted communism and boosted the economy production of the country by 300% with the 5 year plan. 3 times within 5 years! The growth of the economy during that time was phenomenal. Poor starving farmers suddenly became as rich as a middle class white-collar worker and the economy skyrocketed. Within 40 years, the USSR suddenly became a leading superpower with the most production, economy, and military force the world has even seen. However, after Stalin's death, a corrupt leader took his place and declared many wars against asia which cost more than the country can afford. To add insult to the injury, he build a unfeasible space projects and adopted a ridiculous and impractical 5 year plan, unlike what Stalin did, that bankrupted the country. If someone as smart and clever as Stalin took his place instead, Russia's science, production, economy, healthcare, and education would far exceed the US, China, and japan combined. Infact, many professionals predict that if North korea unites with south korea, their economy and production would exceed the US due to their planned economy and centralized workforce. Additionally, N. korea has many resources but somewhat limited economy due to their massive military and corrupt leader, Kim jong ill. If the koreans decides to unite the country, we will see a new superpower that exceeds the US, China and japan. Additionally, they should pay the workers if they have complete the requirements that the government assigned. Not paying them for slacking off. For example, they should make a rule that says each farmers must collect and give 20 kg of wheat to the government within a months, otherwise they’re pay will be cut by 60%. This way, communist will not slack off and everyone will be truly equal. I believe that this is the way the world should be. On the other hand, capitalism makes people do terrible things like exploting others, destroying nature, slowing technological progress and many more negative things because of their greed. The rich will use their money to make poor people work for them for almost nothing which makes them gain profit. If communism is adopted world wide, I believe that the world will be a much better place. There will be no starvation, economy will sky rocket due to the poor gaining the ability to be able to purchase stuff. The rich will remain rich and the poor will gain more wealth. This way, we will achieve world peace and everyone will be happy. Technological progress will increase exponentially, economy and production will skyrocket and education and health will be a lot better. May communism rule once again.
Politics - 6 Answers
Random Answers, Critics, Comments, Opinions :
1 :
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1027154/why_did_communism_fail.html?cat=37 Begsus D telos
2 :
Sorry man, Communism was a dying machine from day one, because the only way to get rich was to steal so everyone did and the system went completely rotten. There is too much waste in a society that rewards theft and doesn't reward work. ...
3 :
in practice communism ignores common man and causes undue suppression. look at the indian State of West Bengal , Communists ruled the State for 34 years . During the latest phase they became the law to themselves like Gestapos
4 :
Communism has failed every single time it has be tried in the past. Like you, each generation thinks if they could only tweak it here or there it would be successful. No offense, but do you really think you're more intelligent than all of the rulers in human history? I don't think so. You mention farmers should only be paid if they produce what the government wants them to. This would absolutely stifle innovation.. nobody would be trying to produce more than what they have been told to produce. There would be no incentive to do so. Also, considering the recent flooding and tornados in the farming regions of the US that have destroyed millions of acres of farmland, what would happen to these farmers under your plan? They can't produce the wheat needed and others would not be producing extra to cover for them because they don't have to. Farmers who couldn't produce would starve due to no fault of their own as would most of the country due to lack of crops. There are many other problems with communism but the major one is removing incentives to prosper and lift yourself out of poverty. Please do some more research.
5 :
Communism looks great on paper but it has failed to produce the utopia that was believed to ensue. To be honest neither are perfect by any means. Look into how many people were executed by your beloved Stalin, and if communism was so peaceful why did the USSR continue going to war? I'm not saying capitalism is perfect but it has advantages as well as communism. There aren't many starving in the USA, the USA has the highest GDP in the world. I can see why you would omit these facts just like the way you blame the collapse on something other than communism. It is very inefficient unless there is the threat of death. I would much rather be poor in a capitalist society than dead for speaking my mind in a communist one.
6 :
The simple physics of Darwinism - you get more of what you reward, less of what you punish. The Marxist credo "From each according to their ability, to each according to their need." ...rewards Need & punishes Ability. Capitalism rewards Ability & punishes Need. Evolution progresses because life naturally strives for superiority. Marxism enforces equality. When you understand these simple principals you understand why Marxism fails every time it's tried. You understand why Marxist countries build fences to keep people in & Capitalists nations build fences to keep people out. America elects a Marxist President & the Economy crashes. It's just physics.
